5 Best Decision Making Activities for Middle School Blog Feature
Bri Stauffer

By: Bri Stauffer on June 25th, 2019

Print/Save as PDF

5 Best Decision Making Activities for Middle School

Career Readiness | Middle School | Decision Making

If you teach career readiness in middle school, you likely need to incorporate a wide variety of professional and 21st Century skills in your lessons.

As a career readiness curriculum developer, we work with teachers like you every day looking for new resources to help students build these skills.

While there are a ton of resources out there related to 21st Century skills like communication, teamwork, and media literacy, teachers tell us there are a few topics that are a bit harder to tackle.

One of those topics is decision making, because there aren’t many age-appropriate resources available to help teach decision making to middle schoolers!

While our digital curriculum includes a learning module on critical thinking, our curriculum isn't the right fit for everyone.

Business&ITCenter21 is a full-fledged curriculum system designed to teach dozens of career readiness skills. However, some teachers are only looking for supplemental decision making activities and lessons.

To help bridge the gap, we’ve pulled together a list of the five best decision making activities for middle school students:

  1. Decision Making Activity from The Colorado Education Initiative
  2. Informed Decision Making Activity from the Florida Department of Education
  3. “In A Pickle” Decision Making Activity from Carol Miller
  4. Decision Making and Problem Solving Activity from The Sunny Sunshine Student Support Store
  5. Decision Making Middle School Bundle from etiQit

In this blog, we’ll give you some detailed information about each decision making activity so you can decide which one(s) to use.

1. Decision Making Activity from The Colorado Education Initiative


The first option on our list is a decision making activity from The Colorado Education Initiative (CEI).

This six-page resource gives teachers a great outline for introducing students to the steps of decision making.

The CEI defines these steps as:

  1. Identifying a decision that needs to be made
  2. Brainstorming possible options
  3. Identifying possible outcomes for the options
  4. Making a decision
  5. Reflecting on the decision



The lesson plan outlines each step of the decision-making process to your students as well as ideas and teaching tips.

In addition, you’ll get a three-page handout for students that provides more context and structure for going through the decision-making process.

The only downside to this resource is if your students have trouble thinking of possible decision-making scenarios, you’ll need to provide some examples yourself.

You can prepare for that with a quick brainstorm before your class to ensure your students stay on track throughout the lesson.

If you’re looking for an activity that comes with pre-created scenarios, the next option could be a better fit for you!

2. Informed Decision Making Activity from the Florida Department of Education


Another great resource for teaching career readiness skills is the Florida Department of Education (DOE) Educator’s Toolkit.

In the toolkit, you’ll find a lesson plan called Informed Decision Making that focuses on the importance of seeking information before making a decision.

Specifically, students learn about the decision-making process and then apply that knowledge to scenarios.

To accomplish this, the activity is broken into two parts.

First is the “poker chip activity,” in which you’ll highlight the importance of having as much information as possible prior to making a decision.

Then, you’ll move onto the larger portion of the lesson to explain the Florida DOE’s seven steps of decision making:

  1. Defining the problem
  2. Gathering information and resources
  3. Listing options
  4. Comparing options
  5. Making a decision
  6. Making a plan of action
  7. Evaluating the decision

After you explain each step, students will apply the process to different scenarios and you’ll end by discussing the decisions as a class or in groups.

Overall, this resource from the Florida DOE is a great way to tie decision making into other topics in your career readiness classes.

The only downside is that there isn’t much variety when it comes to the provided scenarios.

If you want more than four options to give your students relevant examples, check out the next resource on our list!

3. “In A Pickle” Decision Making Activity from Carol Miller


The “In A Pickle” decision making activity is provided by Carol Miller, a popular educator on the Teachers Pay Teachers marketplace.in-a-pickle-decision-making-activity

This resource includes a variety of materials to help you teach good decision making, including:

  • 32 scenario cards
  • Instructions for the teacher
  • Two classroom posters
  • Situation questions for discussion
  • A student worksheet about choices and consequences

In total, the download has 23 pages of content that you can buy for $5.

Overall, this activity provides an excellent introduction to decision making for any middle school classroom.

The only downside is this activity is short unless you find a way to stretch the time.

To dedicate more time to decision making in your lessons, you could combine this option with the next one on the list!

4. Decision Making and Problem Solving Activity from The Sunny Sunshine Student Support Store


The Sunny Sunshine Student Support Store is another well-known vendor on Teachers Pay Teachers with great resources any middle school teacher will love.

One of their popular lessons is the Decision Making and Problem Solving Lesson and Activity.decision-making-problem-solving-activity

This activity-based lesson, referred to as “Stuck in a Jam,” starts with a discussion about making choices and explains the decision making model.

Once students understand the basic concepts, they’ll apply what they’ve learned to a number of different scenarios.

In total, if you purchase this resource ($3.50), you’ll get:

  • A full lesson plan
  • A visual of their decision making model
  • 32 decision making scenario cards

What’s great about this activity is that it ties decision making to another important skill -- problem solving.

However, as with the previous resources, this lesson won’t fill a full class period.

If you’re looking for decision making resources that will fill multiple class periods, the last resource on our list could be perfect for you!

5. Decision Making Middle School Bundle from etiQit


etiQit is another publisher on TpT with resources for middle school decision making lessons.

However, rather than just one resource, they have a full Decision Making Middle School Bundle!decision-making-activity-bundle

This “bundle” is made up of three separate “mini-units” that focus on different aspects of making decisions, such as:

  • Positive risks
  • Negative risks
  • Social pressure

For each mini unit, you’ll find:

  • A teacher presentation (projectable and printable)
  • A student worksheet
  • A practice activity
  • An extension activity
  • A writing activity
  • A “real life challenges” activity
  • Answer keys
  • Instructions and teaching tips

In total, you’ll get more than 20 resources to teach decision making in your classroom.

The only downside to this resource is the cost ($12.50), but the amount of time you save compared to making your own lessons makes this resource well worth the price!

Which Decision Making Activities Are Right for You?

Overall, there's no 'best' resource to help teach decision making skills in middle school. Each of these options could be a good supplement to your career readiness curriculum.

However, if you're looking for a solution that includes decision making and critical thinking among other career readiness skills, consider looking into Business&ITCenter21.

Business&ITCenter21 is used in thousands of classrooms to help teachers like you teach career exploration, professionalism, public speaking, and more.

Overall, it's designed to help you save time with planning, assessing, and grading student work so you can focus on helping your students succeed.

Wondering if Business&ITCenter21 could be a good fit for your classes? Check out our Critical Thinking learning module to find out:

Check Out the Critical Thinking Module >


About Bri Stauffer

Bri collaborates with others at AES to create content that answers your questions about teaching classes, preparing students for certifications, and making the most of the AES digital curriculum.

  • Connect with Bri Stauffer